Comforting Classics for Your Game-Day Gathering: Even if You're Likely to Lose, You'll at Least Win With These Fan Favorites

Take your mind off your team being a fully lost cause with fully loaded nachos and more comfort foods that are perfect for watching sports with your hands over your eyes.

Published November 08, 2024
Illustration of Game Day Snacks

Serious Eats / Inma Hortas

I have a love for lost causes, and I come by it honestly. I spent my formative years playing in the marching band for the worst football team in the country. I do not recall our precise record, but in my mind, we were 0 and 80. Still, I hooted. I hollered. I honked my little saxophone. 

The best thing I can say about those games is that they were short, as the 35 point rule—the high school equivalent of bestowing mercy—meant that the clock was running almost continuously. The second best thing I can say about them is that I got to microwave buffalo chicken tenders when I got home. 

Both my chosen sports teams and my defeat dinners have improved substantially since then. But the core principle remains the same: When you know you’re going to lose, you need unfussy, straightforward comfort food. Only the classics will do.

Consider these recipes a game-day Greatest Hits album, then—surefire crowd-appeasers that no scoreline can sully. These are dishes that can comfort you through the five stages of sports grief (Denial, Anger, Second Anger, Silence, Kicking). The only thing more satisfying is knowing no one can call you a bandwagon fan.

  • Buffalo Wings

    Oven-fried buffalo wings on a white rectangular plate with celery sticks and a glass cup of bleu cheese dressing.

    Serious Eats / Mariel De La Cruz

    A few simple tricks make these oven-baked wings every bit as crisp and juicy as their fried counterparts. Invest the time to air-dry the wings overnight. It’s a form of self-care—a “deepest sympathies” care package from you to future you.

  • The Ultimate Fully Loaded Nachos

    Nachos in foil, with a hand dipping a chip into toppings on a green surface, with a drink in the background

    Serious Eats / Two Bites

    These fully loaded nachos use a cheese sauce and shredded cheese to ensure each chip is maximally melty and saucy, with no disappointing bites. Great nachos won’t fix you, but they won’t make you any worse.

  • Classic Guacamole Recipe

    20210318_BasicGuacamole_LizClayman-9
    Liz Clayman

    Do you like balsamic vinegar in your guacamole? Neither do I. This is a recipe for a simple, classic, precision-calibrated guac with plenty of texture and just a little heat.

  • Hot Spinach-Artichoke Dip

    spinach-artichoke dip hero

    Serious Eats/Morgan Hunt Glaze

    Hot, creamy dips have undeniable retro appeal, with the power to transport you through time and space. One swipe through this chunky-cheesy concoction and you’ll be whisked away to a ‘90s TGIFridays, when everything was beautiful and none of your players were hurt.

    Continue to 5 of 9 below
  • Easy Weeknight Meatballs

    OVerhead view of meatballs

    Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez

    More comforting than spaghetti and meatballs? Skipping right to the meatballs. This weeknight version comes together quickly so you can get right back to pacing in front of the TV.

  • Crispy Bar-Style Pizza

    pizza cut into 8 slices on cutting board

    Serious Eats / Julia Estrada

    Flavor, like dread, develops over time, and this pizza is best if you let the dough ferment in the fridge for a few days. Fortunately, that’s the fussiest part. The thin, crispy pie is adaptable and forgiving, easy for a total pizza novice to shape and bake.

  • 3-Ingredient Mac and Cheese

    20210214-stovetop-mac-cheese-reshoot-vicky-wasik-9
    Photographs: Vicky Wasik. Video: J. Kenji López-Alt

    Evaporated milk is the MVP of this gooey three-ingredient mac and cheese. There’s no faster, easier road to solace than a nostalgic stovetop mac.

  • Honey-Roasted Peanuts

    Bowl of honey roasted peanuts on a textured green fabric next to a glass of beer

    Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez

    The best way to deal with stress is to eat 50 of something. The best thing to eat 50 of are these make-ahead peanuts, double-roasted and tossed in a compulsively snacky honey-butter glaze.

    Continue to 9 of 9 below
  • Rice Krispie Treats

    Overhead view of a torn apart rice krispie treat

    Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez

    Childhood comfort gets an adult upgrade thanks to brown butter, toasted cereal, and a generous sprinkling of kosher salt.

More Serious Eats Recipes